Key Elements of Environmental Justice in the Geothermal Power Plant Resistance Movement

Priyo Fajar Santoso, Bevaola Kusumasari

Abstract


Geothermal energy is currently considered an environmentally friendly, renewable energy source. However, based on empirical data from various countries, geothermal energy production often results socio-ecological losses for the host community. Various environmental justice movements have emerged to protect environment by protesting and providing a counter discourse against the dominant perception that geothermal energy is renewable and environmentally friendly. This article aimed to understand how the strategy and discourse of the Aliansi Selamatkan Slamet (freely translated into Save Slamet Alliance) movement in rejecting the construction of the Baturraden Geothermal Power Plant (PLTPB) in Banyumas by outlining the key elements and specific conditions observed. Aliansi Selamatkan Slamet is intriguing because it has achieved active involvement of various elements through its respective perspectives to jointly reject the construction of the PLTPB. Using a theoretical framework of the movement strategy, we examined how Aliansi Selamatkan Slamet determined the selection of targets, framing, time, and relations in the resistance movement. The method was a qualitative approach: a review of primary data in the form of interviews and written documents. The results indicate sociopolitical conditions, relations between organizations, and organizational cultures also influence the strategies and discourses that the Aliansi Selamatkan Slamet movement created.


Keywords


geothermal energy; environmental justice movement; movement strategy; movement discourse

Full Text:

PDF

References


Abuya, Willice O. 2017. “Resource Conflict in Kenya’s Titanium Mining Industry: Ethno-Ecology and Redefinition of Ownership, Control, and Compensation.” Development of Southern Africa 34 (5): 593–606.

Ali, Saleem H. and Andrew Singh Grewal. 2006. “The Ecology and Economy of Indigenous Resistance: Divergent Perspectives on Mining in New Caledonia.” The Contemporary Pacific 18 (2): 361–392.

Anguelovski, Isabelle. 2011. “Understanding the Dynamics of Community Engagement of Corporations in Communities: The Iterative Relationship between Dialogue Processes and Local Protest at the Tintaya Copper Mine in Peru.” Society and Natural Resources 24 (4): 384–399.

Ballard, Chris and Glenn Banks. 2003. “Resource Wars: The Anthropology of Mining.” Annual Review of Anthropology 32: 287–313.

Ballard, Richard, Adam Habib, Imraan Valodia, and Elke Zuern. 2005. “Globalization, Marginalization and Contemporary Social Movements in South Africa.” African Affairs 104 (417): 615–634.

Banks, Glenn. 2002. “Mining and The Environment in Melanesia: Contemporary Debates Reviewed.” The Contemporary Pacific 14 (1): 39–67.

Bebbington, Anthony. 2007. “Social Movements and the Politicization of Chronic Poverty.” Development and Change 38 (5): 793–818.

Bebbington, Anthony, Denise H. Bebbington, Jeffrey Bury, Jeannet Lingan, Juan P. Muñoz, and Martin Scurrah. 2008. “Mining and Social Movements: Struggles over Livelihood and Rural Territorial Development in the Andes.” World Development 36 (12): 2888–2905.

Bebbington, Anthony, Samuel Hickey and Diana Mitlin, eds. 2008. Can NGOs Make A Difference? The Challenge of Development Alternatives, London: Zed

Bosi, Lorenzo. 2007. “Social Movement Participation and The ‘’Timing’’ of Involvement: The Case of The Northern Ireland Civil Rights Movement.” in Research in Social Movements, Conflicts and Change Volume 27, edited by Patrick G. Coy. Emerald Group Publishing Limited, 37–61.

Bury, Jeffrey and Adam, Kolff. 2002. “Livelihoods, Mining and Peasant Protests in the Peruvian Andes.“ Journal of Latin American Geography 1 (1): 3–16.

Camacho, David E. 1998. “The Environmental Justice Movement: A Political Framework.” in Environmental Injustices, Political Struggles: Race, Class, and The Environment, edited by David E. Camacho, Durham: Duke University Press, 11–30.

Cole, Luke W. and Sheila R. Foster. 2001. From the Ground Up: Environmental Racism and the Rise of the Environmental Justice Movement. New York: New York University Press.

Conde, Marta. 2017. “Resistance to Mining. A Review.” Ecological Economics 132: 80–90.

Craig, William and Gavin Kenneth. 2018. Geothermal Energy Heat Exchange Systems and Energy Piles. London: ICE Publishing.

Dowd, Anne-Maree, Naomi Boughen, Peta Ashworth, and Simone Carr-Cornish. 2011. “Geothermal Technology in Australia: Investigating Social Acceptance.” Energy Policy 39 (10): 6301–6307.

Dwivedi, Ranjit. 2001. “Environmental Movements in the Global South Issues of Livelihood and Beyond.” International Sociology 16 (1): 11–31.

Escobar, Arturo. 2001. “Culture Sits in Places: Reflections on Globalism and Subaltern Strategies of Localization.” Political Geography 20 (2): 139–174.

Fraser, Nancy. 1997. Justice Interruptus: Critical Reflections on the ‘Postsocialist’ Condition. New York: Routledge.

______. 1999. “Social Justice in the Age of Identity Politics: Redistribution, Recognition, and Participation.” in Culture and Economy after the Cultural Turn, edited by Larry Ray and Andrew Sayer, London: SAGE Publications Ltd, 25–52.

Glassley, William. 2010. Geothermal Energy: Renewable Energy and The Environment. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.

Haarstad, Håvard and Arnt Fløysand. 2007. “Globalization and The Power of Rescaled Narratives: A Case of Opposition to Mining in Tambogrande, Peru.” Political Geography 26: 289–308.

Honneth, Axel. 2001. “Recognition or Redistribution? Changing Perspective on the Moral Order of Society.” Theory, Culture & Society 18 (2-3): 43–55.

Horowitz, Leah S. 2010. “’’Twenty Years is Yesterday’’: Science, Multinational Mining, and The Political Ecology of Trust in New Caledonia.” Geoforum 41 (4): 617–626.

Interview with Adhyatmo Ryanto (President of Badan Eksekutif Mahasiswa Universitas Jenderal Soedirman 2017). November 11, 2018.

Interview with Cendikia Nuur Kholik (Chairman of Aliansi Gerakan Reforma Agraria Banyumas). November 16, 2018.

Interview with Marsha Azka (Pemuda Baru Indonesia, Banyumas Branch). November 16, 2018.

Interview with Panji Mulkillah (Research and Media Division of Aliansi Selamatkan Slamet). November 1, 2018.

Interview with Suharyanto (Local youth from Cilongok, Aliansi Pekerja Seni Kontra Penindasan). November 16, 2018.

Jasper, James. 2004. “A Strategic Approach to Collective Action: Looking for Agency in Social-Movement Choices.” Mobilization: An International Quarterly 9 (1): 1–16.

Kirsch, Stuart. 2007. “Indigenous Movements and The Risks of Counter Globalization: Tracking The Campaign against Papua New Guinea's Ok Tedi Mine.” American Ethnologist 34 (2): 303–321.

Klandermans, Bert. 2004. “The Demand and Supply of Participation : Social-Psychological Corelates of Participation in Social Movement.” in The Blackwell Companion to Social Movements, edited by David A. Snow, Sarah A. Soule, and Hanspeter Kriesi, Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 360–379.

Klare, Michael T. 2001. Resource Wars: The New Landscape of Global Conflict. New York: Metropolitan Books.

Kretschmer, Kelsy and David S. Meyer. 2007. “Platform Leadership: Cultivating Support for a Public Profile.” American Behavioral Scientist 50 (10): 1395–1412.

Kuecker, Glen D. 2007. “Fighting for the Forests Grassroots Resistance to Mining in Northern Ecuador.” Latin America Perspective 34 (2): 94–107.

Kunreuther, Frances. 2011. “Grassroots Associations” in The Oxford Handbook of Civil Society, edited by Michael Edwards. New York: Oxford University Press, 55–67.

Kunze, Conrad and Mareen Hertel. 2017. “Contested Deep Geothermal Energy in Germany-The Emergence of an Environmental Protest Movement.” Energy Research & Social Science 27: 174–180.

Liazos, Ariane and Marshall Ganz. 2004. “Duty to the Race: African-American Fraternals and the Right to Organize.” Social Science History Journal 28 (3): 485–534.

Martinez-Alier, Joan. 2009. “Social Metabolism, Ecological Distribution Conflicts, and Languages of Valuation.” Capitalism Nature Socialism 20 (1): 58–87.

Martinez-Alier, Joan, Leah Temper, Daniela Del Bene, and Arnim Scheidel. 2016. “Is There a Global Environmental Justice Movement?” The Journal of Peasant Studies 43 (3): 731–755.

Meyer, David S. and Suzanne Staggenborg. 2012. “Thinking about Strategy” in Strategies for Social Change, edited by Gregory M. Maney, Rachel V. Kutz-Flamenbaum, Deana A. Rohlinger, and Jeff Goodwin. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 3–22.

Miller, George T. Jr. 2006. Sustaining the Earth: An Integrated Approach (8th ed.). London: Brooks.

Ministry of Energy and Natural Resources. 2015. “Rencana Strategis Kementerian Energi dan Sumber Daya Mineral Tahun 2015–2019”. April 13. https://www.esdm.go.id/assets/media/content/Renstra_KESDM.pdf

Mohai, Paul, David Pellow, and J. Timmons Roberts. 2009. “Environmental Justice.” Annual Review of Environment and Resources 34, 405–430.

Muradian, Roldan, Joan Martinez-Alier, and Humberto Correa. 2003. “International Capital Versus Local Population: The Environmental Conflict of the Tambogrande Mining Project, Peru.” Society and Natural Resources 16 (9): 775–792.

North, Liisa L. and Laura Young. 2013. “Generating Rights for Communities Harmed by Mining: Legal and Other Action.” Canadian Journal of Development Studies 34 (1): 96–110.

Patton, Michael Quinn. 2002. Qualitative Research and Evaluation Methods. California: Sage Publications.

Pellizzone, Anna, Agnes Allansdottir, Roberto De Franco, Giovanni Muttoni, and Adele Manzella. 2015. “Exploring Public Engagement with Geothermal Energy in Southern Italy: A Case Study.” Energy Policy 85: 1–11.

______. 2017. “Geothermal Energy and The Public: A Case Study on Deliberative Citizens Engagement in Central Italy.” Energy Policy 101: 561–570.

Pellow, David N. 2016. “Toward Critical Environmental Justice Studies: Black Lives Matter as an Environmental Justice Challenge.” Du Bois Review-Social Science Research on Race 13 (2): 221–236.

Perreault, Tom. 2013. “Dispossession by Accumulation? Mining, Water and the Nature of Enclosure on the Bolivian Altiplano.” Antipode 45 (5), 1050–1069.

Pulido, Laura. 1996. Environmentalism and Social Justice: Two Chicano Struggles in the Southwest. Tucson: University of Arizona Press.

Romanach, Lygia. Simone Carr-Cornish, and Grace Muriuki. 2015. “Societal Acceptance of an Emerging Energy Technology: How is Geothermal Energy Portrayed in Australian Media.” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 42: 1143–1150.

Schlosberg, David. 2007. Defining Environmental Justice: Theories, Movements, and Nature. New York: Oxford University Press.

______. 2012. “Climate Justice and Capabilities: A Framework for Adaptation Policy.” Ethics & International Affairs 26 (4): 445–461.

Shortall, Ruth, Brynhildur Davidsdottir, and Guðni Axelsson. 2015. “Geothermal Energy for Sustainable Development: A Review of Sustainability Impacts and Assessment Frameworks.” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 44: 391–406.

Silva-Macher, Jose C. and Katharine N. Farrell. 2014. “The Flow/Fund Model of Conga: Exploring the Anatomy of Environmental Conflicts at the Andes–Amazon Commodity Frontier.” Environtment, Development, and Sustainability 16 (3): 1–22.

Stauffacher, Michael, Nora Muggli, Anna Scolobig, and Corinne Moser. 2015. “Framing Deep Geothermal Energy in Mass Media: The Case of Switzerland.” Technological Forecasting & Social Change 98: 60–70.

Tilly, Charles. 1985. “Models and Realities of Popular Action.” Social Research 52 (4): 717–747.

Tong, Yanqi. 2005. Environmental Movements in Transitional Societies: A Comparative Study of Taiwan and China. Comparative Politics, 37 (2): 167–188.

Urkidi, Leiri and Mariana Walter. 2011. “Dimensions of Environmental Justice in Anti-Gold Mining Movements in Latin America.” Geoforum 42 (6): 683–695.

Young, Iris. 1990. Justice and the Politics of Difference. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.7454/jp.v5i1.207

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2019 Priyo Fajar Santoso, Bevaola Kusumasari